Matlala withdraws plea deal as R228m SAPS tender corruption case heads for trial
Alleged crime kingpin Vusimuzi “Cat” Matlala has withdrawn from his plea and sentencing agreement with the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA), forcing prosecutors to prepare for a full trial in the multimillion-rand SAPS Medicare24 corruption case.
Matlala returned to the Pretoria Specialised Commercial Crimes Court on Monday, where Magistrate Ignatius du Preez declared the plea agreement null and void after the accused declined to accept the court’s recommended sentence.
The businessman had initially pled guilty to charges including corruption, fraud, money laundering and other offences linked to the controversial R228-million Medicare24 Tshwane District contract awarded by the South African Police Service (SAPS).
Under the agreement reached with the State, Matlala was expected to plead guilty, accept a negotiated sentence and cooperate with investigators as a State witness.
However, the agreement collapsed after the court rejected the proposed sentence.
The State and defence had proposed a sentence of 15 years’ imprisonment, with seven years suspended for five years, which would have resulted in an effective eight-year prison term.
Magistrate Du Preez indicated that the proposed sentence was too lenient and recommended an effective 12-year term of imprisonment.
During Monday’s proceedings, Matlala’s legal team confirmed that he would not accept the revised sentence.
“Mr Matlala has been informed by counsel on your behalf, in respect of yourself, accused two and three, that it is your choice to withdraw the plea and sentence as you decline to accept the court’s recommended sentence agreement,” Du Preez said.
“The plea and sentence agreement is then regarded as null and void.”
NPA FORCED BACK TO THE DRAWING BOARD
Speaking outside court, NPA spokesperson Kaizer Kganyago said prosecutors had to accept the court’s ruling and return to preparing the original case.
“It has collapsed. Obviously, there’s a ruling now that the plea agreement is null and void, and we really have to accept what the court has indicated.”
He confirmed that information contained in Matlala’s plea affidavit, including allegations involving senior SAPS officials, could no longer be relied upon as part of the agreement.
“Because now the plea has been deemed to be null and void, nothing that was in that plea can be used.”
The NPA said it would continue with its own investigations through the Investigating Directorate Against Corruption.
Kganyago maintained that the State’s case was not dependent solely on Matlala’s cooperation.
“Our matter in the other case was not dependent entirely on the plea, because we had already arrested people who were involved in this.”
MATLALA TO FACE TRIAL WITH OTHER ACCUSED
The case has been postponed to 11 September 2026, when the State and defence are expected to determine the next steps.
Matlala, along with his companies Medicare24 and Luxo Africa Brand Investments, will now face trial alongside the other accused in the matter.
Before the plea deal, Matlala was among 17 accused facing charges related to the controversial SAPS health services contract.
The three-year contract, awarded in June 2024, had a budget allocation of approximately R360 million, although Medicare24’s successful bid was valued at R228 million.
The contract was later flagged as irregular, with investigations revealing that at least R50 million had already been paid before the agreement was cancelled in May 2025.
The accused include suspended National Police Commissioner Fannie Masemola, Medicare24 Holdings managing director James George Murray, and several senior SAPS officials.
Among those charged are Brigadier Rachel Matjeng, who was previously dismissed from SAPS following a disciplinary process linked to allegations involving Matlala, as well as Brigadier Alpheus Thembinkosi Ngema, Brigadier Patrick Nethengwe, Colonel Tumisho Nehemiah Maleka and Major-General Busisiwe Temba.
Other accused include Brigadier Kirsty Jonker, Brigadier Petunia Lenono, Brigadier Ofentse Tlhoale, Colonel Nonjabulo Mngadi, Colonel Anton Paulsen and Colonel Johannes Monyai.
Masemola remains out on warning, while other accused persons have been granted bail ranging from R40 000 to R80 000.
MATLALA'S OTHER LEGAL BATTLES
The Medicare24 matter is not the only criminal case facing Matlala.
He is also charged with 11 counts of attempted murder linked to alleged failed assassination plots targeting his former partner Tebogo Thobejane, taxi boss Joe Sibanyoni and music producer Seunkie Mokubung, popularly known as DJ Vettys.
That matter is expected to proceed in the Gauteng High Court in Johannesburg from 20 July 2026.
Matlala is also scheduled to appear before the Madlanga Commission of Inquiry on Wednesday, 15 July, where issues around alleged criminal networks, police corruption and interference in the criminal justice system are expected to be examined.
He previously appeared before Parliament’s ad hoc committee in late 2025.
Past allegations have linked Matlala to the so-called “Big Five” organised crime network, which has been associated with claims of drug trafficking, contract killings and other criminal activities. Matlala has denied these allegations.
The collapse of the plea agreement means prosecutors will now pursue the full trial route, with the State insisting it remains confident in the evidence gathered against Matlala and his co-accused.
ALSO READ
